He got out a baking sheet and washed the potatoes, then cut them into cubes and sprinkled on rosemary. Putting them on the tray with the chicken, he rubbed the whole thing with olive oil, salt, and spices from a small jar. Washing his hands, he put the tray in the oven.
“I asked the butcher for the easiest recipe possible, and that’s what he came up with. Not bad, right?”
I shrugged.
“The only problem,” he added, “is that it takes over an hour to cook.”
“Over an hour!” The thought of waiting made my head hurt. I hadn’t eaten since breakfast, and my stomach was empty to the point of nausea.
Grant lit a candle and produced a deck of cards. “To distract us,” he said. He set a kitchen timer and sat down across from me.
We played war by candlelight, the only game either of us knew. It kept us just entertained enough to avoid passing out on the table. When the timer buzzed, I set plates on the table and Grant cut the breast of the chicken into thin slices. I pulled a leg off the golden-brown bird and started to eat.
The meal was delicious, the flavor inversely proportional to the amount of effort that had gone into the preparation. The meat was hot and tender. I chewed and swallowed huge mouthfuls, then pulled off the other drumstick before Grant could reach for it, eating the seasoned skin first.
Across from me, Grant ate a slice of breast with his knife and fork, cutting bites one at a time and eating slowly. His face showed both the pleasure of the food and the pride of the accomplishment. He put down his knife and fork, and when he looked across the table, I could see he was enjoying the sight of my ravenous hunger. His watchfulness made me uncomfortable.
I put down my second drumstick, all bones. “You know it won’t, right?” I asked. “Be us?”
Grant looked at me with confusion.
“At the drugstore, the old couple, the slapping and winking; it won’t be us. You won’t know me in sixty years,” I said. “You probably won’t know me in sixty days.”
His smile faded. “Why are you sure?”
I thought about his question. I
“What happened after fifteen months?”
I looked at him, my eyes pleading. When he realized the answer, he looked away, embarrassed.
“But why not now?” It was the exact right question, and when he asked it, I knew the answer.
“I don’t trust myself,” I said. “Whatever you imagine our life would be like together, it won’t happen. I’d ruin it.”
I could see Grant thinking about this, trying to grasp the chasm between the finality in my voice and his vision of our future, and bridging the divide with a combination of hope and lies. I felt something, a combination of pity and embarrassment, for his desperate imaginings.
“Please don’t waste your time,” I said. “Trying. I tried, once, and failed. It’s not possible for me.”
When Grant looked back to me, the expression on his face had changed. His jaw was clenched, his nostrils slightly flared.
“You’re lying,” he said.
“What?” I asked. It was not the response I had expected.
Grant pinched the skin along his hairline with the fingers of one hand, and when he spoke, his words were slow and careful. “Don’t lie. Tell me you’ll never forgive me for what my mother did, or tell me every time you look at me you feel sick. But don’t sit here and lie to me, talking about how it’s your fault we can never be together.”
I picked up the chicken bones, peeling fat away from the tendons. I couldn’t look at him, needed time to process what he was saying.
“I’m not lying.” It was all I could think of to say.
Grant dropped his fork, the metal clattering against the ceramic plate. He stood up. “You’re not the only one whose life she ruined,” he said, then walked out of the kitchen and into the night.
I locked the door behind him.