Plain Kate

She had heard the tale: that witches could not lie. People said that as the devil gave witches power, God bound their tongues to truth. It did not seem to her a likely story, and she did not trust Linay.

Linay’s tin-gray eyes glittered as he said, “I want you well. But there are other things I want more. And a swarm of fish might be just a beginning. Think on it. Your shadow for a heart’s wish. Is it such a bad bargain?”

“What I wish,” she said, “is that you would go away.”

And as if answering a command, Taggle slunk around the awning prop, sprang out, swarmed up Linay’s shirt, and attacked his ear. Linay shouted and spun and flailed like a man who’d stepped on a beehive. All his dignity and all his menace gone in a whirl of squeaks and ungainly limbs. Plain Kate laughed. Finally the cat went flying out of the melee and bolted across the square. There was scattered applause.

Linay bowed. “Until tomorrow,” he said to Kate, and sauntered off, bleeding.

¶

When they opened the smokehouse the next day, the fish were bones and ashes. They fell to dust at a touch. Only Plain Kate’s trout were still plump, smoke-yellow and pink, perfect.

The master of the smokehouse summoned her, and she had to go stand before him in the drizzle with her strong hands curled into silent fists. The master was a grand man, his hands fat and many-ringed, his white hair dressed in curls, yellowed with smoke, smelling of fish. His chair was grand too, with arms carved into the form of leaping salmon: her father’s work. She remembered helping him with it, his big calloused hands over her small calloused ones as he taught her the way of wood grain—oh, her hands had been so small, and she had been happy.

“I have decided,” the master said, leaning back in the beautiful chair, dry under his awning, “that your catch will be split among the men whose fish were in the batch. Since, after all, only luck has spared your fish alone.”

Only luck. He was daring her to contradict. No one thought it was luck. She looked at the salmon, so strong she could almost sense the whip of their muscle. There was a little crowd gathered at her back. She thought the salmon were swimming hard against the current of their looks. “That’s fair,” she said at last. “But I didn’t burn the fish.”

“As I say, girl,” he frowned, “only luck.”

“It’s not luck, it’s witchcraft,” she said, and at her back the silence hardened. “The stranger, Linay. He drew the fish.”

Big Jan, behind her, said what Linay had said: “But you caught them.”

“The fish will be split,” the master said. “And that’s enough from you, Kate Carver.”

Plain Kate could feel how it was going to be. Linay was useful; he was powerful. Those that knew he was a witch wanted his protection; those that didn’t would take an easier target. Stranger though he was, people knew that Linay was not someone to cross. He was powerful as a cornered dog. If the town was going to choose someone to blame for the hard times coming, it wouldn’t be Linay.

Plain Kate turned on her heel, swam silently through the knot of people, and went back to her stall. The bow was lying on her countertop. She wanted to smash it, but it was beautiful. It was quiet and strong. She picked it up, and went back to work.

She was watching for Linay, but he still managed to sneak up on her. “Fair maid of the wood,” he said, making her jump. “How goes the work?”

Plain Kate steadied herself and shrugged. “It will be a good bow,” she said. “I am a good carver.”

“Too good, they say.” He tapped her nose. “They call you ‘witch-child’ already, Katie girl.”

“If they do, it’s because of you.”

He caught her words and sang them back at her:

If they do it’s because of you

What they see is because of me

That may be, that may be,

But I see what I say and I say what I see

He smiled at her. “Do you know what happens to witches, Plain Kate? Have you seen the fires?”

The sour smell from the smokehouse suddenly seemed stronger. “Over a few fish?” Plain Kate tried a laugh; it came out tight.

“Well,” said Linay with a bow, “there might be more.”

“Go away. Or I’ll set my cat on you.”

And he went away. But not very far.

¶

The next day there was no catch—or no catch of fish. Old Boyar brought in three boots. Big Jan caught a dead dog. On the next day the nets were wholly empty. The whole week there was no catch, and the grain barges didn’t come, and rain fell like a long fever.

Then Boyar took a punt upriver into the fog banks, and the next day the boat came back drifting. Boyar was lying on the deck like a king of old, not dead but sleeping—an unnatural sleep from which he could not be woken.

Talk in the market turned to muttering. Plain Kate saw Big Jan swat Taggle from his nest atop a coil of rope. The cat was kicked and cursed from every stall.